
For today’s list, I thought I would have a little bit of fun and list songs that should absolutely not be played at a bar. And since most bars have a jukebox with a web search for songs, things can get a little dicey. Most of these songs are great songs in their own right, but are the complete opposite of a song designed to “get the people going”.
1.) “Sister Ray” – The Velvet Underground
“Sister Ray” happens to one of the Velvet Underground’s most groundbreaking songs. That says a lot for a band that is considered to be one of the most innovative bands of all time. But “Sister Ray” also happens to be 17 minutes long of pure noise. In an act of sheer stupidity, I once tried to play this song at a bar and after about 10 minutes, someone finally changed the song.
2.) “Bridge Over Troubled Water” – Simon & Garfunkel
Any fun you’re having will automatically be zapped away if this song comes on. People go out to get away from their problems, and “Bridge Over Troubled Water” is sure to bring people back to reality. If you do dare to put this song on, expect at least one person to shout out: “Who the fuck put on ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water?’”
3.) “Desolation Row” – Bob Dylan
Unless your drinking friends are a bunch of college English professors, who like to argue over what Ezra Pound and TS Elliot are fighting about, or why Einstein is disguised as Robin Hood (and what are his memories doing in a trunk?), then this 11 minute song is probably not for you.
4.) “I Will Follow You Into the Dark” – Death Cab For Cutie
Really any Death Cab song is questionable for jukebox consumption, but a title like that sounds down right creepy late at night.
5.) “This Radio Clash” – The Clash
Ironically, this song was supposed to be a dance song with its funky rhythms and early hip-hop beats. Time has not been kind to this song, and its 4 minutes seem just about as long as “Sister Ray”.
6.) “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” – Pink Floyd
I know some people love to put on Floyd at bars, but I prefer not to think about my own mortality and worry about the educational establishment when I’m drinking. But “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” has got to be the worse: it takes about 4 minutes for the guitars to come in and another 5 before there is any singing.
7.) “Shiny Happy People” – R.E.M.
This song isn’t quite as bad as people make it out to be, but almost everyone around will bitch about its very existence turning almost everybody into very angry people. Also, the song sounds like a B52s song, and if you want the B52 just put them on and that way everyone will be happy.
8.) “My Hometown” – Bruce Springsteen
Springsteen has so many great songs meant for a jukebox. This song is not one of them.
9.) “Day of the Lords” – Joy Division
Much like Death Cab, any Joy Division song is kind of off limits here (with the possible exception of “Love Will Tear Us Apart”), but “Day of the Lords” stands out with its icy production and crawling pace.
10.) “Well Well Well” – John Lennon
The entire Plastic Ono Band album should not be played under any circumstances, but this song especially. If you dislike Yoko Ono, the references to sex might put you off, but not as much as Lennon screaming for two minutes before finally tearing his voice near the end of the song.